Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Finally, Some Good News From Massachusetts

Cross-posted from Critical Condition on National Review Online.

Finally, some good news with the Massachusetts insurance price-control saga: an appeals board of attorneys from the state’s Division of Insurance has overturned Governor Deval Patrick’s denial of Harvard Pilgrim Health Care’s requested rate increases. The Boston Globe reports that the “panel…found that rate increases Harvard Pilgrim initially sought in April are reasonable given what it must pay to hospitals and doctors.”
Insurers yesterday cheered the ruling, which bodes well for three other companies now before the appeals board with their own cases against capped rates.

“The decision shows what we have been saying all along,” said Lora Pellegrini, president of the Massachusetts Association of Health Plans, a trade group based in Boston. “The denial of carrier rates was inappropriate.”
The other insurers in the state can hold out hope that the appeals board will give them the same treatment, saving them several months of uncertainty and litigation.

Meanwhile, in Washington, it didn’t take long for the Obama administration to try Deval Patrick’s tactics on for size. Everyone knows that insurers across the country are going to have to raise premiums in order to account for all of the new mandates in the Affordable Care Act. But the President is trying to have his cake and eat it too, warning insurers that the government will not allow “unreasonable premium increases.” He would doubtless cheer on the implosion of the private health insurance business, but consumers would not.

Both in Massachusetts and across the nation, genuine attempts at reducing the cost of health insurance will require a completely different approach to health care reform: one that incentivizes patients to make prudent choices about health spending, and one that frees insurers from the mandates that prevent them from creating affordable insurance products.

Too many Republicans are formulating their health care positions by melding a general free-market disposition with a split-the-difference political posture. These Republicans need to understand that the desire to repeal Obamacare is neither a temper-tantrum nor an ideological litmus test. Rather, as a policy matter, repeal is critical to the economic fortunes of tens of millions of Americans, for whom affordable health insurance is increasingly out of reach.

1 comment:

  1. It is a common dilemma -- because deep down we all know and what will replica handbags happen. We'll either choose a bag which is rather too small, and put in thousands of items, all of which become crumpled and worn, and almost inevitably, unreachable without unpacking the entire contents. The alternative is with a bag which is really far too big. Feeling delighted dior replica handbags with ourselves, we see all the extra room we have after providing the necessities, and revel in walking around omege replica watches through our home looking for any other things that we can squeeze into the rolex replica extra pockets and spaces we still have remaining.