Wednesday, January 12, 2011

The Fiscal Risk of Employer Dumping under PPACA

Cross-posted from The Agenda on National Review Online.


There’s been much discussion on the blogosphere of whether or not repealing PPACA is fiscally responsible. I actually agree with a lot of what Ezra Klein says in this piece, in which he responds to conservative criticisms that Democrats manipulated the CBO to provide favorable projections for the new law.

However, I also agree with Kevin Williamson’s basic point: the government has a history of underestimating future spending, and overestimating future tax revenue. Hence, just because the CBO says PPACA will reduce the deficit doesn’t mean it will actually happen.

Indeed, as I write today for National Review Online, there are features of PPACA that are highly likely to result in far greater spending than PPACA anticipates:
David Brooks, in a recent New York Times column, highlighted Obamacare’s most serious flaw: PPACA incentivizes companies to drop health coverage for their employees. Employers who drop coverage have to pay a fine, but the fine is cheaper than offering health insurance, and even the employees can be better off — they buy their insurance on state-based “exchanges,” where they can take advantage of the law’s new subsidies. (Americans making less than 400 percent of the federal poverty level are eligible for subsidized coverage on the exchanges.) AT&T has calculated that it would save $1.8 billion a year by dumping its workers into the government’s lap.

Companies are keeping quiet about their plans for now, but make no mistake: If Obamacare remains the law of the land, nearly every corporation in America will do what AT&T has contemplated. So will cash-strapped state governments.

Last March, the CBO projected that 26 million people will take advantage of Obamacare’s exchange subsidies in 2019, at a cost of $109 billion that year. But that number is based on the assumption that of the 162 million people who have employer-sponsored insurance today, only 4 million — 2.5 percent — will switch.

In other words, the projection of $109 billion is absurdly low; it underestimates Obamacare’s cost by trillions of dollars.

In a recent Politico column, former budget officials Douglas Holtz-Eakin and James Capretta calculated what would happen if the CBO’s estimates were somewhat off. By their math, if the households below 250 percent of the federal poverty line ($55,125 for a family of four) that now have employer-sponsored health insurance were to migrate to Obamacare’s exchanges, spending on those exchanges would more than triple, resulting in trillions of dollars in additional liabilities.

Ezra responds to this issue in a more recent post:
Let me talk about employer dumping, which I’ve left out until now. The basic concern here is that employers will stop being such nice guys and giving people health care and instead dump them into the exchanges so they can buy it at subsidized rates. I don't think this will happen: If we were going to see it, we'd have seen it in Massachusetts, which, like the ACA, makes it much cheaper for employers to dump workers into the exchanges. But there's no evidence (pdf) that it’s been happening. Employer coverage has been shockingly resilient given the recession.

That said, I can see the argument that it’d be good if it did happen. Basically, it would mean that employers stop paying employees with health-care insurance and begin paying them with cash. That’s basically how the Wyden-Bennett bill worked, and both Brooks and I liked that bill. If it happens in an unstructured way in the ACA, it could cause more disruption, but it could also be a positive step that makes the bill look more like Wyden-Bennett.
Austin Frakt also came out with a detailed post on the subject, in which he responds to the work of Holtz-Eakin et al.:
One thing I believe is not included [in Holtz-Eakin’s estimate] are the income and payroll taxes levied on the higher wages those additional exchange-enrolled people will receive…I don’t know how much in income taxes would be collected, but it is something Holtz-Eakin and Smith could compute. It would somewhat offset the $1.4 trillion gross price. (The CBO likely calculated the offset, so one could just triple it. I haven’t yet found the CBO’s figure on this. Have you?)

Another question is whether all employers who theoretically might benefit from “dumping” will actually drop offers of coverage firm-wide. Holtz-Eakin and Smith don’t assume they all will cut coverage in this way (firm-wide). That’s because if coverage is not offered to lower-wage workers (for whom dumping is economically beneficial to employers), it can’t be offered to higher wage workers either. But there’s another proposed route: “[T]here may be incentives for firms to ‘out-source’ their low-wage workers to specialist firms (that do not offer coverage) and contract for their skills.”

Of course, this is something firms can (and do) do today. Moreover, it’s not costless to outsource. There are transaction costs that would partially offset the benefit. Thus, it is not likely that all firms for which outsourcing would appear beneficial (and which don’t already out-source) would do so. Finally, if this were something all firms that could theoretically benefit would do, we should see a considerable crowd-out effect in Massachusetts. So far, there is no evidence of it.

I’m not saying that the ACA won’t contribute to erosion of employer-sponsored coverage. It will. But it isn’t likely to be as an extreme reaction as some predict, nor will it cost as much as Brooks thinks. The $1.4 trillion price tag he suggested ignores some offsetting factors. It’s just not plausible.
Let’s summarize the counter-arguments raised by Ezra and Austin and go through them one-by-one:

1. Employers in Massachusetts didn’t dump their employees, so it’s unlikely to happen nationwide.

It’s not as straightforward as Ezra may believe to extrapolate the Massachusetts experience nation-wide. There are several reasons for this. Most importantly, most large employers have offices in multiple states; they are unlikely to dump coverage in one state while maintaining coverage in another. Also, the cost of insurance continues to increase, to a point that is increasingly unsustainable for companies; that, combined with PPACA’s “Cadillac tax,” increases the incentive for more employer dumping in the future.

2. Even if dumping did happen, it would be a good thing, because it would help foster more of an individual market for health insurance.

As to fomenting an individual market: yes, it would be better if we had a market for health insurance in which individuals purchased insurance for themselves, rather than receiving it willy-nilly from their employers. However, the individual market under PPACA will be heavily subsidized by the government, dramatically increasing federal spending—which is the whole point of the Brooks/DHE critique. If the exchanges weren’t subsidized, or at least subsidized less heavily, Ezra and Austin would have a stronger argument.

3. The fiscal impact of employer dumping is less than DHE and others estimate, because DHE’s estimates leave out the regained payroll taxes that would accrue to the government.

Austin is right to point out that there is at least some revenue that would flow back to the government from payroll taxes. But it’s not clear that this offset would be significant; indeed, whatever its size, it is guaranteed to get smaller over time, because health care costs rise far faster than wage growth. The PPACA subsidies are designed to guarantee that individuals pay no more than 10 percent of their income for health insurance; hence if wages stay flat and health care grows, the government’s liability grows over time.

4. Maybe employer dumping wouldn’t happen firm-wide: firms will outsource their low-wage work, and continue to offer coverage to their higher-wage employees.

It’s possible that some employers might try the strategy that Austin suggests of using outsourcing to maintain health coverage for their employees. As Austin himself points out, this is something that firms can do today. Furthermore, increasing unemployment, by incentivizing firms to outsource peripheral capabilities to lower-wage countries, leads to higher welfare spending and lower tax revenues: i.e., increased deficits.

To me, this is the real debate we should be having about the fiscal prudence of Obamacare. And then, we need to ask: how would the CBO score Obamacare if it were required to make more realistic assumptions about employer dumping?  Here’s hoping that someone in Congress asks the CBO to do just that.

61 comments:

  1. Sort out what small businesses are doing in Massachusetts. Last I saw it published, they are not dropping health insurance. Suppose I dropped health insurance for my employees. Since I have to compete for quality workers I would have to pay them enough to make up for the loss of insurance. I would also have to pay the penalty. It would cost me more to dump insurance.

    Steve

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am looking forward to reading most recent blog posts. I was extremely remarkable. You have truly unique style. Keep up the outstanding efforts! I must say that you have a big talent! When I saw your work I was extremely remarkable. You have truly unique style...

      Delete
  2. Rising HI costs has been blamed for stagnant wages, since employers calculate total compensation. Employees would feel entitled to the savings, or would feel like they took a pay cut. Are the projected AT&T savings taking this into account?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Steve: you have to compete for quality workers, but quality (high-paid) workers don't qualify for the exchanges, so it doesn't matter (esp since we still have the employer tax exclusion). On the other hand, for low-to-middle-income salaried employees, who are more easily replaceable and who do qualify for the exchange subsidies, they get a better deal on the exchanges.

    Charles: I addressed this point in question #3 above. Short answer: yes, to a degree.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Its a great graph detailing by writer that is showing how government moves like this I never seen before like these type of things its really good. pay for dissertation || dissertation at low price

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Obamacare’s exchanges, spending on those exchanges would more than triple, resulting in trillions of dollars in additional liabilities.
    vimax australia

    ReplyDelete
  7. The total review of that process doing in previous Government are shown by writer graphically it is easy to learn everything it shows well. custom essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is extremely interesting for me to read this article. Thanks for it. I like such topics and anything connected to this matter. I definitely want to read more on that blog soon.
    Vimax
    Vimax
    Vimax

    ReplyDelete
  9. Its a great graph detailing by writer that is showing how government moves like this I never seen before like these type of things its really good.Thanks for it. coursework by writerslounge

    ReplyDelete
  10. If you want help of a dissertation writer, So you can choose dissertation writers on awesommessay.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. Its a great graph detailing by writer that is showing how government moves like this. Thanks for it. essay writers uk , coursework writing service

    ReplyDelete
  12. Numerous people are joining Open University in Dubai to increase their standard of living.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Employement is a problem for everyone. If you need a great resume or admission essays address Custom-Essays-Online.com :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Professional team of buy-custom-essays.net can help you with your writing assignments 24/7.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I totally agre with you - our government usually exceeds their capabilities and underestimate costs. So we cann't be sure that CBO and PPACA will tell us real situation. Thanks for your great post. I found here a lot of interesting things. Please keep it good posting.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. College Homework Help is just few clicks away. Any subject, any time, just email us the details.

    College Homework Help


    ReplyDelete
  18. If you are a college or a University student, you certainly know how hard it is to obtain better scores if half-researched coursework papers are submitted to the College or University. Dissertation Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  19. Are you an aspiring graduate and worrying about submitting a perfect top class dissertation? Do not worry as DissertaionProposalWriting.co.uk comes up with best possible writing solutions. Dissertation Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  20. Get custom written Marketing Essay,Thesis, Research Papers and Dissertation by trained Writers at very Reasonable prices.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The Internet has brought forth never-before facilities for people in many fields. In the field of education, particularly for students in colleges and Universities, the Internet is very useful device to search and find a plethora of information and knowledge, on many subjects required for their studies. Recent developments have made available yet another excellent facility of writing the course work papers by experts, on behalf of the needy students which they can submit to their class and achieve exemplary grades with high marks. History Essay Co. UK is a leading website on this service.

    ReplyDelete
  22. All women want to apply these cheap makeup to attract the attention of men.

    ReplyDelete
  23. we at socialstudyhomeworkhelp.com can provide you with the required assistance to garner great grades by completing your homework in time with prowess.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Our website provides a great help to the students community by catering them support in the bulk size homework given to them from their institutions. We are one of the largest homework service providers unique of its kind covering almost all the varieties (i.e., essays, reports, summaries, presentations, research papers, assignments etc.).

    ReplyDelete
  25. Term Paper Writing Service is a one stop site for all your term paper writing needs.

    ReplyDelete
  26. In case of homework, this group helps us in subjects like Computers, Lau and Business, Management, Philosophy, Chemistry, Literature, Finance, Geography, Political Science and other subjects too. Hence, when we are in need of any tutorial help from any tutor, this group assists us a lot by providing expert tutors to us. College Homework Help |
    Business Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thesis Writing Service or Dissertation Help, just send us an email and we will get that done by our qualified writers within deadline for resonable rates.

    Thesis Writing Service

    ReplyDelete

  28. Coursework Writing Service is an online website that has been solely created for the benefit of the students.

    ReplyDelete
  29. The key to better scores at Universities or colleges is submission of original Coursework Writing Help.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The real and best cosmetics selling online. Buy best cheap bobbi brown makeup at http://www.jeanmakeup.com.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Get Business Essay Writing Service, Term Papers, Dissertation and Thesis by trained Writers at very Reasonable prices.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Best Dissertation Proposal Writing Service. We can also help with complete Dissertation Writing Service, Essay, Coursework or Thesis. Best Writers available!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thank you for writing such a wonderful article, it is really going to motivate people to achieve something big and dream bigger in future.

    ReplyDelete
  34. - Unrestricted Coins
    - Auto Update
    - Support All Devices
    - Interconnection Encryption Script
    - Easy-to-use Interface
    http://onlinegamescheats.info/msp-hack/
    Msp Hack
    onlinegamescheats.info/msp-hack/

    ReplyDelete
  35. Thanks a lot for writing such a great article!

    ReplyDelete
  36. There has only been one Punxsutawney Phil. He has been making predictions for over 119 years! http://awriter.org/customwritingscom/

    ReplyDelete
  37. By the way, Thank you for sharing with us, and we sincerely hope you will continue to update or post other articles.
    cara jitu mengobati tumor ginjal tanpa operasi

    ReplyDelete
  38. Take time to work out where technology belongs in your real estate business and where it doesn't by following these 5 steps.assignment writing

    ReplyDelete
  39. Get the best Dissertation and Custom Essay Writing Service from our Qualified Writers. Trust the best and never lament. Attempt our Essay Help and see the distinction in your evaluations. Cheap Dissertation Writing Services

    ReplyDelete
  40. Great article post, I truly interesting the manner in which you highlighted some important points. Thanks quite definitely, I appreciate your post.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Much thanks for this brilliant site. elegantly composed and useful substance you have.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Thanks for sharing this awesome post , your blog deserves to be in my bookmark list. Send Gifts To pakistan

    ReplyDelete
  43. Thanks for sharing amazing information !!!!!!
    Please keep up sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The blog article very surprised to me! Your writing is good.
    In this I learned a lot! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  45. This site is really a walk-through it really is the details you wanted concerning this and didn’t know who to inquire about. Glimpse here, and you’ll absolutely discover it. https://flexgenius.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete

  46. The effectiveness of IEEE Project Domains depends very much on the situation in which they are applied. In order to further improve IEEE Final Year Project Domains practices we need to explicitly describe and utilise our knowledge about software domains of software engineering Final Year Project Domains for CSE technologies. This paper suggests a modelling formalism for supporting systematic reuse of software engineering technologies during planning of software projects and improvement programmes in Project Centers in Chennai for CSE.

    Spring Framework has already made serious inroads as an integrated technology stack for building user-facing applications. Spring Framework Corporate TRaining the authors explore the idea of using Java in Big Data platforms.
    Specifically, Spring Framework provides various tasks are geared around preparing data for further analysis and visualization. Spring Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  47. What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. textbook answers

    ReplyDelete
  48. Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. Ko-te-Ipurangi-Manuhiri-Visa

    ReplyDelete
  49. Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks Wisata-India-Visa

    ReplyDelete
  50. Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it. 먹튀사이트

    ReplyDelete
  51. What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. 오피

    ReplyDelete
  52. Someone Sometimes with visits your blog regularly and recommended it in my experience to read as well. The way of writing is excellent and also the content is top-notch. Thanks for that insight you provide the readers! 17609 valleyview ave, cleveland, oh 44135

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hey, I am so thrilled I found your blog, I am here now and could just like to say thank for a tremendous post and all round interesting website. Please do keep up the great work. I cannot be without visiting your blog again and again. Visa de turista de Nova Zelanda

    ReplyDelete
  54. Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. طلب التأشيرة الهندية عبر الإنترنت

    ReplyDelete
  55. Test banks created by educators can be used to create assessments that are standardized across multiple classrooms or schools.

    ReplyDelete